If you're a long time reader of this blog (*cue sound of crickets chirping*), or if you have perused the archives at all, you may know that the very first review I wrote early this year was of a sandwich from Paradise Bakery & Cafe. So, I suppose it is only fitting that the first establishment to receive multiple reviews is that same Paradise Bakery. Now why do I end up going here so often you ask? Well, there are many reasons I could give, but the real one is that my wife enjoys the place and, since she is the boss, we eat there with some frequency. Draw your own conclusions about me based on that statement if you will, but that's the way it is.
So anyway, today Paradise Bakery becomes the first multi-review joint as we take a look at their Turkey Cranberry sandwich. And aside from providing the first review of more than one sandwich from the same place, it at the same time provides the first review of essentially the same sandwich from different places. Nice! I already gave a brief overview of Paradise Bakery in my previous review, so I think here I'll just provide some very general likes and dis-likes. In general, the things I like about Paradise are that it's always clean, the service is nice, and they use fresh ingredients to good effect. The downers, in my opinion, are that it tends to be a little pricey and I seem to always leave hungry. As I mentioned, the main reason I end up here so often is that my wife loves it. I asked her just what it is that she likes about it and her reply was "the cookies and the Southwest Chicken Caesar Salad." Obviously, this doesn't help us at all with sandwich analysis, but there you go.
Now then, back to the sandwich at hand. See what Paradise Bakery would like you to believe this sandwich looks like here. Compare that to the image above and, as usual, you will see there is a slight discrepancy. Here's the ingredients that go into this one:
- Type of Bread: Paradise Molasses
- Condiments/Dressing(s): Mayonnaise, Cranberry Sauce
- Toppings: Oven Roasted Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato
Pretty standard list of ingredients for a sandwich of the turkey cranberry variety, with the one foray into the unknown here being the type of bread used. In my opinion, the key to executing a turkey cranberry sandwich well is striking a balance between the sweetness of the cranberry sauce and the savoriness of the mayo and turkey. Let's see how Paradise Bakery fared in this regard as well as the other areas we judge:
- Quantity/Value: 3/5 - As I mentioned earlier, the main gripe I would say I have with Paradise Bakery in general is that it seems pricey for what you get. That was the case with this sandwich as well. For over $7 (which, it should be noted, also included a cookie), I expect there to be enough sandwich to vanquish my hunger. Unfortunately, after I downed my sandwich, I still had enough room to put away the last half of my wife's salad as well.
- Originality: 4/5 - While not totally original by any stretch of the imagination, having a turkey cranberry on the menu at least shows that the establishment has some sense of adventure when it comes to making sandwiches. And in addition to that, Paradise gets some style points for putting everything inside their unique molasses-tinged bread which you won't find just anywhere.
- Appearance: 7/10 - As you can see from the pictures, this is a pretty good looking sandwich. Here's another one in case you missed the first one:
Obviously it's not close to the photo of the sandwich you see on their website or menu, but they never are. Obviously some care was taken in putting the sandwich together and the deep and vibrant colors of the lettuce, cranberry sauce and bread contrast nicely with each other. - Quality/Freshness: 9/10 - This is where Paradise usually excels and today was no exception. The bread was obviously fresh, but although it was soft and spongy, it hadn't been left around long enough for anything to seep into the bread and make it soggy. The vegetables were cool and crisp - everything as it should be.
- Taste: 16/20 - Alright, now let's take a look at where the rubber meets the road. The freshness of the ingredients as mentioned above obviously contributed in a positive fashion to the taste of this sandwich. Unfortunately, so did the quantity/value rating. What I mean by that is I wish there would have been more turkey on my turkey cranberry sandwich. As you can see from the photo, the amount of turkey is less than the thickness of a tomato slice and in my book, that just is not getting the job done. Also, the sweet/savory balance I mentioned earlier fell a little too far on the sweet side for my taste. This again would be remedied by some more turkey on that bad boy or at least a little more mayo. All in all though, a pleasing version of a new classic.
